"Forever Magic" is the 2nd issue in the The Book of Elements saga, and the number 50 overall issue of W.I.T.C.H.
Summoned by five transfiguring cards, the five Guardians take a trip to the past and live alternate lives without magic. They also get to travel to the future after they give up their powers. After seeing the past and future, the girls realize that their bond is unbreakable, even without magic.
- Will's alternate future is an author and she has also published a fantasy almost-bestseller based on the guardians.
- Irma's alternate future is a dolphin trainer. Her eternal gift is her ability to 'get along with aquatic animals'.
- Martin works as an editor in the Heatherfield Tribune in the W.I.T.C.H girls' alternate future.